Wednesday, January 15, 2014

Roanoke: Violent Beginnings - Part I

   Part one of a four part series on the lost colony of Roanoke.



England began to sail over the Atlantic Ocean to the seemingly obscure New World during the late sixteenth century. Exploration and colonization of Virginia began in 1578, when Queen Elizabeth gave Sir Humphrey Gilbert a patent to colonize America. Nearly a decade later in 1587 the first English colony in America is established on Roanoke Island and ended in total disaster, the disappearance of the entire colony. The colony of Roanoke vanished from the English map in 1590; the reason was that the population from the colony assimilated into the surrounding Indian communities because England was more preoccupied with Spain and showed little support for the American colony.
Sir Humphrey Gilbert originally proposed the idea of a northwest passage to the oriental coast over the northern tip of America in 1566. He believed that, “if England secured such a route, she would establish herself as a major commercial power and eventually come to rival Spain’s rapidly growing overseas empire.”[i] Spain was a powerful nation that was gaining enormous wealth from the West Indies and Central America. The threat from Spain grew over the next few years and finally in 1578 Gilbert was granted an exclusive patent by Queen Elizabeth to discover and colonize American lands not yet inhabited by Spain.[ii] He must plant a new colony within six years or he would lose his right to colonize the New World.
Just a few months after the patent was granted, Gilbert formed a fleet to sail over the Atlantic Ocean. The voyage was a failure and Gilbert quickly returned to England. A few years later he dispatched a small frigate led by mariner Simon Fernandez on a reconnaissance mission in 1580. Fernandez was previously a Spanish navigator who turned rogue and lived as a pirate until he was arrested by England and agreed to serve the crown as a navigator in exchange for his freedom. After his release he aided Gilbert and, later, Sir Walter Raleigh on their attempts to reach America and he was an essential cog to the American expeditions for the next decade.[iii]
The voyage was a success, with Fernandez traveling along the North American coast and returning before the end of summer. This trip strengthened Gilbert’s resolve and he was determined to attempt to reach America before his exclusive patent expired.[iv] In early 1583 he embarked with a fleet of five ships to America.
Throughout the voyage sickness and dissention spread through the sailors, and it led to several of the ships sailing home early. When one of the ships sank off the coast of Nova Scotia the expedition began to sail back to England, failing to establish a potential shoreline to build a fort and colony on. On the way home the ships ran through a furious storm and the ship Sir Humphrey Gilbert resided on sank. The captain of the voyages flagship, the Golden Hind, recorded this horror: “For in that moment, the frigate was devoured and swallowed up of the sea.”[v] Gilbert was, as Queen Elizabeth notably said, “a man noted of not good hap [fortune] by seas.”[vi]
Queen Elizabeth transferred the patent in 1584 to the newly knighted Sir Walter Raleigh.[vii] The patent demanded he establish a colony or he would lose the right of colonization in America, the same circumstance Sir Humphrey Gilbert was under. For the next year Raleigh turned his quarters at Durham House into a station for mariners, promoters and scholars. Richard Hakluyt, John White, Thomas Hariot, Simon Fernandez and others were recruited to draft plans for sailing to America and establishing a colony.[viii] During this time the general location of the colony was decided on. Raleigh wanted a colony that was far north of Florida and the Spanish garrisons located in the region and he selected the Chesapeake Bay because of Fernandez’s familiarity with the region.
In less then a year the first voyage to Virginia commenced. It was a small reconnaissance mission consisting of two ships and several skilled men and soldiers. Most importantly it had the scientist Thomas Hariot and artist John White on board and was led by Philip Amadas and Arthur Barlowe with Simon Fernandez navigating. The exact plan for the expedition was never given, but the primary reasons were to locate a suitable site for the future colony, make contact with the local natives and to take extensive notes of the area. [ix]
The expedition sailed to America and landed on the island of Hattaras, which is located on the outer banks of Pamlico Sound. They proclaimed the land as property of the English crown. The land was fertile and seemingly untouched with cedar, pine, cypress and sassafras trees covering the land. [x] They slowly began to explore the region with Hariot taking extensive notes of everything he encountered and White drawing renderings of the natives, fauna and wildlife.
Three days after landing first contact was made with the native Indians as three Indians approached the ships because of their curiosity. These Algonquian Indians were from the town of Pomeiooc, which Granganimeo was the weroance, or chief.[xi] The following day fifty more Indians came to the English and began to barter and welcome the visitors. This included Granganimeo as well. Over the following weeks relations were peaceful and often included Indians visiting on board the English ships. Arthur Barlowe observed that the Indians behavior was as “mannerly and civil as any of Europe.”[xii]
That was the warmest reception the English received from the natives as when they ventured to Roanoke Island, Arthur Barlowe and Thomas Hariot were initially greeted with hostilities from Indians on the island, but they began to welcome them after they showed trade goods and offered them. Conversely, Philip Amadas and Simon Fernandez sailed a pinnacle to the northern shore of Albemarle Sound and had a skirmish with the native Indians. The Secotans and Weapemeoc Indians killed a small number of the English, sending a clear message that not all the natives were welcoming.[xiii]








[i]James Horn, A Kingdom Strange: The Brief and Tragic History of the Lost Colony of Roanoke (New York: Basic Books, 2010), 8.
[ii]Richard Hakluyt, The Principall Navigations Voiages and Discoveries of the English Nation (Cambridge, 1965), 135-37.
[iii]Lee Miller, Roanoke: Solving the Mystery of the Lost Colony (New York: Penguin, 2000), 171.
[iv]David B. Quinn, Set Fair for Roanoke (University of N. Carolina Press, 1985), 7.
[v]Richard Hakluyt, Principall Navigations (Cambridge, 1965), 296.
[vi]Kenneth Andrews, Trade, Plunder and Settlement (Cambridge, 1984), 194-97.
[vii]Karen Ordahl Kupperman, Roanoke: The Abandoned Colony (United States: Barnes & Noble, 1993), 12.
[viii]David B. Quinn, Set Fair for Roanoke (University of N. Carolina Press, 1985), 7-9, 45-46.
[ix]James Horn, A Kingdom Strange (New York: Basic Books, 2010), 41.
[x]Ibid, 43.
[xi]Thomas Hariot, A Briefe and True Report of the New Found Land of Virginia (New York: Dover, 1972), 46.
[xii]David B. Quinn, The Roanoke Voyages 1584-1590 (New York: Dover, 1991), 101-104.
[xiii]James Horn, A Kingdom Strange (New York: Basic Books, 2010), 54.

Monday, December 23, 2013

Totalitarian Candor - Part II


“The immediate aim of the Communists is the same as that of all other proletarian parties: formation of the proletariat into a class, overthrow of the bourgeois supremacy, conquest of political power by the proletariat.” – Karl Marx







Marx’s proposed steps for a utopian society started with the abolishment of private property. Private property in Marxist terms refers to property within capitalist class society and thus is a social and historical category; the term does not refer to personal objects for use in society. He claimed that bourgeois private property is the most important expression of social exploitation; to abolish private property is to abolish individuality and freedom. The key is that this would eliminate freedom. He goes on to explain it as free trade, free selling and free buying; this is the center of the problem with the bourgeois and capitalism. As he wrote, “private property is therefore the product, the necessary result of alienated labor and private property is thus derived from the analysis of the concept of alienated labor, that is alienated man, alienated life, and estranged man.”[i] Marx viewed free buying as the heart of the issue of exploitation and abolition of private property is a critical cog in his communist philosophy.

The next step is abolition of the bourgeois family, which Marx asserted would be difficult, but necessary. Marx believed that the family is built upon a foundation of personal gain and to eliminate it is to eliminate capital. The exploitation of children by their parents and the exploitation of wives by husbands would end; Marx said, “The point is to do away with the status of women as mere instruments of production.”[ii]

 In addition to abolishing the family, Marx proposed that home education must be replaced with social education. To argue his point, he claimed that home education is already a form of social education as the lessons taught are determined by the current social condition. He goes on to say that communists are not the inventors of social education, but a party that wishes to change the influence of the bourgeois society over it.

Next is possibly the most monumental in the path towards communism, and that is the abolishment of countries and nationalities. Marx went on to claim that, “the working men have no country and they will not lose what they do not already have.”[iii] He believed that when the antagonism between classes diminishes, the hostility of one country to the other would also diminish and eventually cease. He said that this is one of the first conditions for the emancipation of the proletariat classes and is needed to fully unite the proletariat against the bourgeois.

Those are the main steps to a communist utopian society as defined by Karl Marx; the main steps to dismantle the bourgeois and spread equality to the proletariat. With these steps a perfect society would be unavoidable in Marx’s beliefs, a society without the worker being alienated from his labors and without wealthy upper class getting richer via the exploitation and oppression of the proletariat.

Communism also abolishes eternal truths in its quest for equality; it eliminates all religion and morality. These are tools of the bourgeois; to do away with them is a must in Marx’s beliefs. He said that the tools of religion and morality are nothing more then just a construction of man. He claimed that religion was “opium of the people”[iv] and went further on to say that, “to abolish religion as the illusory happiness of the people is to demand their real happiness.”[v] This is what a society that is fundamentally socialist is supposed to manifests as; a society that has people as the center point and gives contempt and disdain to any form of exploitation of men.

As it reads, Karl Marx’s concept of communism is a socialist society where men are no longer enslaved and exploited by the bourgeois, but where men have “true happiness” unhindered by social class structures. Communism is a process that is not instant, but is a slow progression that begins with the revolution of the working class. The Revolution begins politically as the first objective is for the proletariat to wrestle the monopoly of democratic power away from the bourgeois. He explained this revolution; “the proletariat will use its political supremacy to wrest, by degrees, all capital from the bourgeoisie, to centralize all instruments of production in the hands of the State.” [vi]

Karl Marx had grandiose ideas for communism and how it could become a brilliant key to the social equality of men. He outlined the perfect society, but never had the opportunity to see how it materialized. He died in 1883 and it was not until 1917 that Vladimir Lenin implemented his version of communism; it was born from a forced revolution that overpowered the Russian Empire.

Lenin ignored Marx’s statement that the revolution would be gradual and mostly political, he took matters into his own hands in what is now called the February Revolution.[vii] This form of ruling, more appropriately called Leninism, lasted until 1991 and did not follow with Marx’s ideology. It overturned the current bourgeois, but then Lenin became part of the new bourgeois. It was simply an exchange of one for of exploitation for another.

Marx’s hope was for communism to end capitalism and the exploitation of the proletarians and it has not happened yet. The evolution of the communist party has been tainted under the new leaders, ideologists and philosophers of today. Although it would be difficult to argue that it is not what Karl Marx would have wanted, as he repeatedly emphasized the idea to not be satisfied with the current political climate of a nation. He was an advocate for action, as is evident by the quote engraved on his tomb, “The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways, the point however is to change it.”[viii]






[i] Erich Fromm, Marx’s Concept of Man, (Continuum: 2003), p 36
[ii] Karl Marx, Capital I, (J.M. Dent & Sons Ltd: 1946), p 105-6
[iii] Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, The Communist Manifesto, (Filiquarian Publishing: 2005), p 31
[iv] Ibid, p 32
[v] Ibid, p 34
[vi] Karl Marx, Frederick Engels and Werke, Towards a Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, trans. A. Wood, p 378
[vii] Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, The Communist Manifesto, (Filiquarian Publishing: 2005), p 35
[viii] Karl Marx, Theses on Feuerbach, (1845), p 15