Monday, December 23, 2013

Totalitarian Candor - Part II


“The immediate aim of the Communists is the same as that of all other proletarian parties: formation of the proletariat into a class, overthrow of the bourgeois supremacy, conquest of political power by the proletariat.” – Karl Marx







Marx’s proposed steps for a utopian society started with the abolishment of private property. Private property in Marxist terms refers to property within capitalist class society and thus is a social and historical category; the term does not refer to personal objects for use in society. He claimed that bourgeois private property is the most important expression of social exploitation; to abolish private property is to abolish individuality and freedom. The key is that this would eliminate freedom. He goes on to explain it as free trade, free selling and free buying; this is the center of the problem with the bourgeois and capitalism. As he wrote, “private property is therefore the product, the necessary result of alienated labor and private property is thus derived from the analysis of the concept of alienated labor, that is alienated man, alienated life, and estranged man.”[i] Marx viewed free buying as the heart of the issue of exploitation and abolition of private property is a critical cog in his communist philosophy.

The next step is abolition of the bourgeois family, which Marx asserted would be difficult, but necessary. Marx believed that the family is built upon a foundation of personal gain and to eliminate it is to eliminate capital. The exploitation of children by their parents and the exploitation of wives by husbands would end; Marx said, “The point is to do away with the status of women as mere instruments of production.”[ii]

 In addition to abolishing the family, Marx proposed that home education must be replaced with social education. To argue his point, he claimed that home education is already a form of social education as the lessons taught are determined by the current social condition. He goes on to say that communists are not the inventors of social education, but a party that wishes to change the influence of the bourgeois society over it.

Next is possibly the most monumental in the path towards communism, and that is the abolishment of countries and nationalities. Marx went on to claim that, “the working men have no country and they will not lose what they do not already have.”[iii] He believed that when the antagonism between classes diminishes, the hostility of one country to the other would also diminish and eventually cease. He said that this is one of the first conditions for the emancipation of the proletariat classes and is needed to fully unite the proletariat against the bourgeois.

Those are the main steps to a communist utopian society as defined by Karl Marx; the main steps to dismantle the bourgeois and spread equality to the proletariat. With these steps a perfect society would be unavoidable in Marx’s beliefs, a society without the worker being alienated from his labors and without wealthy upper class getting richer via the exploitation and oppression of the proletariat.

Communism also abolishes eternal truths in its quest for equality; it eliminates all religion and morality. These are tools of the bourgeois; to do away with them is a must in Marx’s beliefs. He said that the tools of religion and morality are nothing more then just a construction of man. He claimed that religion was “opium of the people”[iv] and went further on to say that, “to abolish religion as the illusory happiness of the people is to demand their real happiness.”[v] This is what a society that is fundamentally socialist is supposed to manifests as; a society that has people as the center point and gives contempt and disdain to any form of exploitation of men.

As it reads, Karl Marx’s concept of communism is a socialist society where men are no longer enslaved and exploited by the bourgeois, but where men have “true happiness” unhindered by social class structures. Communism is a process that is not instant, but is a slow progression that begins with the revolution of the working class. The Revolution begins politically as the first objective is for the proletariat to wrestle the monopoly of democratic power away from the bourgeois. He explained this revolution; “the proletariat will use its political supremacy to wrest, by degrees, all capital from the bourgeoisie, to centralize all instruments of production in the hands of the State.” [vi]

Karl Marx had grandiose ideas for communism and how it could become a brilliant key to the social equality of men. He outlined the perfect society, but never had the opportunity to see how it materialized. He died in 1883 and it was not until 1917 that Vladimir Lenin implemented his version of communism; it was born from a forced revolution that overpowered the Russian Empire.

Lenin ignored Marx’s statement that the revolution would be gradual and mostly political, he took matters into his own hands in what is now called the February Revolution.[vii] This form of ruling, more appropriately called Leninism, lasted until 1991 and did not follow with Marx’s ideology. It overturned the current bourgeois, but then Lenin became part of the new bourgeois. It was simply an exchange of one for of exploitation for another.

Marx’s hope was for communism to end capitalism and the exploitation of the proletarians and it has not happened yet. The evolution of the communist party has been tainted under the new leaders, ideologists and philosophers of today. Although it would be difficult to argue that it is not what Karl Marx would have wanted, as he repeatedly emphasized the idea to not be satisfied with the current political climate of a nation. He was an advocate for action, as is evident by the quote engraved on his tomb, “The philosophers have only interpreted the world in various ways, the point however is to change it.”[viii]






[i] Erich Fromm, Marx’s Concept of Man, (Continuum: 2003), p 36
[ii] Karl Marx, Capital I, (J.M. Dent & Sons Ltd: 1946), p 105-6
[iii] Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, The Communist Manifesto, (Filiquarian Publishing: 2005), p 31
[iv] Ibid, p 32
[v] Ibid, p 34
[vi] Karl Marx, Frederick Engels and Werke, Towards a Critique of Hegel’s Philosophy of Right, trans. A. Wood, p 378
[vii] Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, The Communist Manifesto, (Filiquarian Publishing: 2005), p 35
[viii] Karl Marx, Theses on Feuerbach, (1845), p 15

Monday, September 23, 2013

Totalitarian Candor - Part I

“You are pitiful insolated individuals; you are bankrupts; your role is played out. Go where you belong from now on – into the dustbin of history!” – Leon Trotsky



1917 was a year full of dramatic turmoil for the Russian Empire. It was the year of the February Revolution as well as the October Revolution and the year ended with the formation of the Cheka (Bolshevik security force) in late December.[i] The Russian Empire collapsed and the Romanov Dynasty ended in February, but it was not until the October Revolution that the Bolsheviks instituted themselves as the new government. A brutal Civil War broke out in October of 1917 and lasted until 1922 when the Bolsheviks squelched the remaining opposition to Communism. It was in 1922 that the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was born and the world was given its first taste of Communism.  
The Bolsheviks were one of the two factions that split from the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party, the other being the Mensheviks. The faction gained power and officially split away from the RSDLP in 1912; they were led by Vladimir Lenin. Once the Bolsheviks gained full control of the Russian Empire, they were able to form it into a Socialist Republic. This new ideology instituted by the Bolshevik Communist Party, often called Leninism, lasted until 1991 and did not follow with Marx’s original ideology of Communism. In Marxist terminology, it was an exchange of one form of exploitation for another, not the progressive step Communism was supposed to be. Marxist views were more natural and included the abolishment of the ruling class, not the exchange of exploitation that happened under Bolshevik rule.
Karl Marx and Frederick Engels were the founders of an economical movement that would erupt and turn civilization upside down; Communism. It was an economic and political idea created to give the working man, or the proletariat, hope in this world. Marx’s expectation was for communism to engulf capitalism and then end exploitation of the proletarians. His key writing on this was Manifest der Kommunistischen Partei, translated The Communist Manifesto. In this pamphlet he outlines the problems with the bourgeois, the wealthy class, and why overthrowing them is necessary.
            The history of Marx and the birth of communism began with his research in the factories of the Industrial Revolution which began in the 1830’s. He was disgusted by the conditions of workers in the factories and blamed free buying, or capitalism, saying that this form of economics devalues the worker and turns him into a commodity to be exploited by the bourgeois. Marx was angered by what he called the “alienation of man”, the separation of man from his labor. The frustration and anger at this treatment is evident at the end of The Communist Manifesto when he writes, “…the Communists everywhere support every revolution movement against the existing social and political order of things.”[ii] His anger at the present state of the working class outweighed his plan for the perfect, utopian society of Communism.
            Karl Marx met Frederick Engels for the first time in the summer of 1844[iii]. Engels was a radical socialist proponent whose writing caught the attention of Marx. Engels wrote for Robert Owen’s publication titled, “New Moral World”.[iv] Marx and Engels became fast friends and collaborated on several publications together, including The Communist Manifesto, which they released in 1848. Within the pages they outlined the idea of reaching a utopian society in ten steps. These steps range from the abolition of private property to the abolition of inheritance rights, the centralization of communication and transportation by the State and free education.
             The predominate theme within all of this is the overthrowing of the bourgeois and abolition of man by destruction of all social classes. Marx also took great strides to show that the Communist party was not separate from the other proletarian parties, but a party that is most interested in coming to the aid of the others. He explains that the Communists are only different from the other proletarian parties in two ways, they bring the common interests of the proletarians to the forefront, “independently of all nationality”[v]; and in the stages of the proletarian and bourgeois struggles, they represent the desires of the entire proletarian movement as a whole. Marx believed that Communist desires were the exact same as all other parties, in that they want to form all the proletariats together and overthrow the bourgeois social order. The coup by the proletariats could only be achieved through Marx’s drastic steps, only then the utopian society yearned for would finally materialize.




[i] Figes, Orlando (1996). A People's Tragedy
[ii] Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. The Communist Manifesto. (Filiquarian Publishing: 2005), p. 54.
[iii] Heaven On Earth, dir. & prod. Brittney Huckabee, 2005. DVD. New River Media & BJW, Inc. 2005.
[iv] Ibid
[v] Karl Marx and Frederick Engels. The Communist Manifesto. (Filiquarian Publishing: 2005), p. 23.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Exploration and Determination


So I'm sailing for tomorrow, my dreams are a-dyin',
And my love is an anchor tied to you, tied with a silver chain
I have my ship and all her flags are a-flyin'
She is all that I have left and music is her name
 
 Though the 15th to 17th centuries, life on land would be considered tough enough, but life at sea during the Age of Exploration was aggrandized. Men and boys at sea would be cut off from land and their families for months and years at a time. They lived on a cramped ship, were prone to diseases and had poor food, were forced to sleep on the open deck of the ship, preformed treacherous duties and received little to no pay.[1] Moreover, the mariners were also at the mercy of the sea and weather and whatever danger they would present. With all these dangers in mind, people would regularly join a crew or even captain a ship in hopes of acquiring enormous wealth and fame. The primary reason to sail during this time was to gain wealth, discover new lands and new riches that were waiting to be plundered. 

Mariners such as Christopher Columbus, Ferdinand Magellan, Henry Hudson and Sir Francis Drake lead explorations in hopes of gaining wealth from the Spice Islands and other lands. A hope that was originally spurred on by The Adventures of Marco Polo, the chronicle of 13th century Italian merchant Marco Polo who spent over 20 years traveling Asia.[2] A single bag of rare goods from the Spice Islands located in Indonesia would give a sailor enough money to buy a home and live comfortably. One main focus of explorers and sailors was finding a sea route to the islands, even if it meant subjecting themselves to years at sea and even death. The prospects of adventure and wealth would outweigh the dangers of the sea for those who committed themselves to sailing. In one idea it is a form of Russian roulette, except with three or four bullets loaded into a revolver instead of just one.

Several famous voyages featured mutinies, which was a surprisingly common occurrence for the extreme punishments it would result it. The literal definition of mutiny is, “revolt or rebellion against constituted authority, especially by sailors against their officers.”  This act happened and failed against Ferdinand Magellan and Sir Francis Drake, resulting in the execution of the mutineers. Often subversive and open rebellion at sea was rewarded with the death penalty; mutiny was often equated to treason, such as when Juan de Cartagena rebelled against Magellan.[3] Other punishable offenses would be as simple as singing a rebellious sea shanty to striking a superior officer. These were punishable with floggings, keel-hauling’s (“dragged round the underneath of the ship”[4]) or even being tarred and feathered.

Once the recalcitrant nature of men is put to the side, the other facts of life at sea are observed. Food, or rations, were typically salted meat, biscuits, ale and sometimes fish. The quality of the food deteriorated because of storage problems, lack of ventilation and poor drainage. The existence of rats and vermin on the ships also affected this; additionally it was not unusual for biscuits to be filled with maggots or weevils.[5] When Magellan sailed through the Pacific Ocean the sailors, in desperate measures, “ate only old biscuit reduced to powder, all full of worms and stinking of the urine that the rats made on it. And we drank water that was yellow and stinking.”[6] Sailors would be so desperate for food during long voyages they would hunt down and sell rats to each other as fresh meat.

In collaboration with the lack of fresh food, vitamin C in particular, is the disease scurvy. It is an easily prevented and cured disease with fresh fruits and vegetables, but lethal if left untreated. It was not until the early 17th century that citrus and a need for vitamin C was discovered as a direct result of scurvy. During this age, scurvy was common because of the lack of fresh food during voyages. It has been estimated that scurvy killed at least two million sailors during the Age of Exploration, more than the amount that succumbed to storms, shipwrecks, and hostile encounters combined.[7] As the disease progresses, the victim becomes increasingly weak and bed ridden, their teeth fall out and old scars will reopen.

Duties aboard a ship from this time would range from cooks (who cooked on an open fire on the top deck of the ship) and barbers (who were also surgeons) to carpenters and gunners. By far the worst duty young sailors, often still apprentices, would have to preform was manning the bilge pump.  Bilge pumps would bail out the bilge water; this is water that does not drain off the deck from rough waters, rain or leaks in the hull. It accumulates inside the ship and would often mix with pitch, urine and other materials on board the ship. Bilge water was notoriously vile and had an overpowering stench that was even lethal at times. A lantern with a burning candle would be lowered down into the bilge and if the candle went out it was a sign of bad air, meaning that whoever went down would possibly die, and sometimes would.[8] The water would also have to be pumped out by hand, difficult and exhausting work to even the strongest seaman.

All of these are just a simple summary of what life on the open sea would entail, and the financial rewards that sometimes awaited those lucky enough to survive a successful voyage. Life at sea was brutal, deadly and treacherous. Even still, people would regularly join a crew or even captain a ship in hopes of acquiring enormous wealth; which did not happen as often as it seems in the history books. For every voyage bringing back millions of pounds or ducats there were many more that only brought back broken and battered mariners.


A letter of marque come from the king,
To the scummiest vessel I'd ever seen,
I was told we'd cruise the seas for American gold
We'd fire no guns-shed no tears
Now I'm a broken man on a Halifax pier








[1] "Ships, Seafarers & Life at Sea." Royal Museums Greenwich. National Maritime Museum, 1 Feb. 2000. Web. 10 Aug. 2013. <http://www1.rmg.co.uk/>.
[2] Corn, Charles. The Scents of Eden (1998), p.4
[3] Woodman, Richard, Mutiny: A Brief History (2005). P. 17
[4] "Ships, Seafarers & Life at Sea." Royal Museums Greenwich. National Maritime Museum, 1 Feb. 2000. Web. 10 Aug. 2013. <http://www1.rmg.co.uk/>.
[5] Ibid
[6] Pigafetta, Antonio, Magellan’s Voyage: A Narrative Account of the First Circumnavigation (1994)
[7] Drymon, M.M. Disguised As the Devil: How Lyme Disease Created Witches and Changed History (2008) p. 114
[8] Oertling, Thomas Ships’ Bilge Pumps: A History of their Development, 1500-1900 (1996), p. 7